Book review: “Cloistered by Catherine Coldstream” – Disorderly Descent into Seclusion.

In a compelling recount of her journey as a nun within the confines of one of Catholicism’s most stringent practices, Catherine Coldstream delves into the intricacies of devotion and suffocating trivialities. The narrative unfurls against the backdrop of profound loss – the passing of her cherished father in 1987 served as the catalyst for a profound spiritual upheaval.

Haunted by the lingering essence of her father and consumed by existential questions concerning the afterlife and the ethereal destiny of the soul, Coldstream embarked on an introspective odyssey spanning three arduous years. Her quest was driven by an insatiable yearning for deeper significance and a boundless wellspring of divine affection. Ultimately, this quest led her to the sanctified enclave of the Carmelites, an austere Roman Catholic order rooted in the ascetic practices of ancient hermits who sought solace in the caverns of mystical Mount Carmel.

Within the hallowed walls of the Carmelite community, Coldstream found herself enveloped in a tapestry of pious rituals and profound contemplation. The rigidity of their traditions intertwined with moments of transcendental beauty, shaping her perspective on faith and the enigmatic nature of existence. Through the lens of her experiences, she vividly portrays the duality inherent in a life dedicated to unwavering devotion—a juxtaposition of spiritual enlightenment and the stifling constraints of ritualistic orthodoxy.

As she navigated the labyrinthine corridors of the Carmelite ethos, Coldstream grappled with the complexities of her own identity, torn between the allure of divine communion and the weight of earthly attachments. Each day brought forth a crucible of emotions, mingling reverence with a sense of confinement—a dichotomy that defined her existence within the cloistered embrace of the order.

The memoir serves as a poignant testament to Coldstream’s profound metamorphosis—a transformation wrought through the crucible of faith and self-discovery. It unveils the intricacies of a journey marked by moments of epiphany and disillusionment, offering readers a glimpse into the paradoxical tapestry of spirituality and human frailty.

Through her evocative prose, Coldstream invites us to traverse the hallowed halls of the Carmelite tradition, where piety converges with the stark realities of human experience. Her narrative, woven with threads of introspection and reverence, stands as a testament to the enduring power of faith and the profound depths of the human soul.

Charlotte Garcia

Charlotte Garcia